Comparing Different Forms of Vitamin C Used in Private Label Skin Care

Vitamin C is a powerhouse ingredient in skincare, renowned for its antioxidant properties, ability to brighten skin, reduce hyperpigmentation, boost collagen production, and protect against environmental damage like UV rays and pollution. However, the pure form, L-ascorbic acid, is unstable and irritating. To address these issues, cosmetic chemists have developed various derivatives that offer improved stability, better penetration, and reduced irritation while still delivering many of the benefits of Vitamin C. Several of the most common forms are discussed below including advantages and disadvantages of each.

(1) L-Ascorbic Acid (Pure Vitamin C)

L-Ascorbic acid is the biologically active form of Vitamin C and the most researched in skincare. It's water-soluble and highly potent, providing strong antioxidant protection, brightening effects by inhibiting melanin production, and collagen synthesis to reduce fine lines. However, its instability is a major drawback—it oxidizes quickly when exposed to air, light, or heat, turning products yellow or brown and reducing efficacy. It requires a low pH (around 3.5) for stability, which can irritate sensitive skin, causing redness or stinging.

Pros: Maximum potency; proven for brightening, anti-aging, and UV protection.

Cons: Unstable; high irritation potential; not ideal for sensitive or acne-prone skin.

(2) Ethyl Ascorbate (3-O Ethyl Ascorbic Acid)

This derivative modifies ascorbic acid with an ethyl group, making it more stable and soluble in both water and oil. It penetrates the skin well and converts to L-ascorbic acid once absorbed, offering antioxidant, brightening, and collagen-boosting benefits. Studies show it may outperform ascorbyl glucoside in penetration, and it's less irritating than pure ascorbic acid. It's stable at a neutral pH, reducing formulation challenges. For these reasons this one of our preferred forms of Vitamin C and used in many of our Private Label Skin Care Products.

Pros: Stable, non irritating, effective brightening and suitable for most skin types.

Cons: Higher cost.

(3) Ascorbyl Glucoside

A stable, water-soluble derivative where ascorbic acid is bound to glucose. It converts slowly to L-ascorbic acid in the skin via enzymes, creating a "reservoir effect" for prolonged benefits. It' has in vitro evidence for antioxidant activity, melanin reduction, and collagen promotion. It is gentle on the skin so good for sensitive skin types and useful for anti-aging and skin brightening.

Pros: High stability; low irritation; gradual release.

Cons: Slower acting; less potent.

(4) Ascorbyl Tetraisopalmitate (Tetrahexyldecyl Ascorbate or THD Ascorbate)

This oil-soluble form esterifies ascorbic acid with fatty acids, enhancing penetration into deeper skin layers. It's highly stable, doesn't require low pH, and converts to ascorbic acid in the skin. Research indicates strong anti-aging effects, including collagen stimulation and UV protection, with minimal irritation. Again this is another favourite used in our Private Label Skin Care products.

Pros: Excellent stability and penetration; non-irritating; hydrating.

Cons: Expensive

(5) Other Notable Forms

Sodium Ascorbyl Phosphate (SAP): A water-soluble, stable derivative ideal for acne-prone skin due to its anti-inflammatory and antibacterial properties. It converts to ascorbic acid and helps with brightening and collagen, but is less potent and not absorbed as well as other forms.

Magnesium Ascorbyl Phosphate (MAP): Similar to SAP but even gentler, with good stability at neutral pH. It's effective for hyperpigmentation and elasticity, making it suitable for sensitive skin but less potent and not as well absorbed as other forms.

Ascorbyl Palmitate: An older, fat-soluble form used as a preservative. It's stable but poorly penetrates and converts inefficiently to ascorbic acid, limiting its benefits.

Glyceryl Ascorbate: A newer hydrated derivative combining ascorbic acid with glycerin for added moisturization. It shows promise in stability and user experience but has less research.

Due to various limitations listed in this group we do not use any of these forms of Vitamin C in our Private label Skin care range.

In summary pure L-ascorbic acid offers top-tier results but is unstable and irritating so derivatives like ethyl ascorbate and ascorbyl tetraisopalmitate provide a balance of efficacy, stability and gentleness, while options like ascorbyl glucoside are ideal for sensitive users. These are considered the best forms of Vitamin C and the ones you will find in our Private Label Skin care range.